Tonight American Idol announced the top 5 finalists. The person kicked off “American Idol” April 28 was Siobhan Magnus. “American Idol’s” most eccentric contestant this season didn’t have the votes to make it into the top 5.

Did America get it right? Who should have gone instead?

Magnus, 19, came from Cape Cod, Mass., with a background in glass-blowing and friends who called themselves Siobhan-bies

Magnus was joined in the bottom two with Casey James and Big Mike Lynche. Next week: The top five take on Frank Sinatra with the help of mentor Harry Connick Jr.

American Idol TOP 5 are as follow: Crystal Bowersox, Lee Dewyze, Michael Lynche (aka Big Mike), Casey James and Aaron Kelly.




Tags: who got kicked off american idol april 28, who got kicked off dancing with the stars april 27, siobhan magnus, dancing with the stars elimination april 27, siobhan magnus american idol, american idol results april 28